Re: New HD-DVD Reviews - BEOWULF, and ASSASSINATION OF JESSE JAMES (by Eddie)

i've bought two hd dvd players--one for myself and one for my gf. money is tight for me, but i am willing to spend it on hd dvd.

Yes Eddie, a number of Blu-ray titles have excessive edge enhancement that result in visible halo artifacts as well. I count on yourself as a reviewer to help convince these studios that this is not desirable in order to improve the quality of releases going forward.

Thanks for your cooperation in this matter.

(still laughing at skyhawk)

Oh Eddie...

Just keep your hearty laughter centered on THIS BLU-RAY CHODE!

-JIMI (the Voodoo Child)
-my new nickname-

Ummm... Eddie I hate to break it to you. But my complaint about EE was not "format" related, nor did I ever suggest it was. It's a studio/transfer thing. As a reviewer, I'm sure you know this. So you can stop laughing now, because that kind of childishness does not lend much credibility to yourself nor your reviews.

Edit: Interesting that in the link Eddie provided I said the following:

Quote:
Yes I'm aware that both formats use the same master, and on top of that likely use the same bit-for-bit VC-1 encode since Warner usually does it this way. I wasn't implying that this EE existed on one format and not the other.

I wonder what Eddie's agenda is? Why would he mislead people here about something so trivial? I hope he doesn't mislead (lie) with the Beowulf review he did also, because I have this one on pre-order!

[Post edited by Skyhawk on Feb 15, 2008]

jimi: that guy is a chode, period.

skyhawk: why don't you pre-order the UK blu-ray version instead? it has a lossless audio track but fewer extras because blu-ray supporters don't like extras according to sony.

(still laughing at skyhawk)

(still disappointed at Eddie's loss of credibility)

skyhawk =

Eddie =



[Post edited by Skyhawk on Feb 15, 2008]

Timmy =