TCM Archives: The Buster Keaton Collection (DVD)

John,

Don't forget Harold Lloyd. (y)

Eddie

You're right, but I'm betting Lloyd would come to mind third.

John

The kids in Bertolucci's "The Dreamers" have debates about who is better, Keaton or Chaplin.

Yeah, but Jackie Chan compares himself to Keaton and Lloyd with nary a mention of Chaplin. (y)

True, Keaton and Lloyd were much more physical than Chaplin, which is why Chaplin probably made the better transition into talkies.

John