10 Reasons Why Physical Media Owns!
" Mehar Gill of Format War Central provides ten reasons for the advantages of disc media.
Connect to Facebook/Twitter, recommend via email and much more.
NOTE: the following article appeared recently on the Format War Central website (followed by reader comments).
10 Reasons Why Physical Media Owns!
by Mehar Gill, December 12, 2008
Let's face it, before the last format war was even over a new one had begun, both formats had to fight an uphill battle, leaving the winner to fight alone for "true" reign of the market. With a slew of pro digital download announcements, we here at Format War Central decided to give Physical Media the spot light by telling the world: "Hey, Physical Media Still Kick's Ass!".
1. People Like Physical Whether its a 12" vinyl record or simply a DVD case, people have always wanted something they could hold, to tell them "Hey, you own that!". Stigma related to this ensures people will always have place in their hearts for years to come.
2. Bit Rates Consumers are a odd bunch when it comes to quality, some are fine with VCD type video playing back on their 55" HDTV, others won't settle for that, they want the best! Physical media is capable of reaching bit rates which currently wouldn't be possible on digitally distributed content for a variety of reasons.
3. You Can't Sell Digital If you're sitting on 50 copies of Doom on HD DVD hoping they'll be worth something one day, don't bother. Depending on the title, you could get a hefty sum of money for it down the line. Unfortunately, the same would not apply to digital content, something tells us your 20GB Xbox 360 HDD filled with the third season of Heroes won't hold much value 20 years down the line; in fact a few months down the line and we're sure the HDD would be worth more than the show! We wonder how much your colorized Casablanca VHS is worth?
4. Unified With Digital Downloads, almost everyone and their sister [company] are releasing a distribution device/platform, it's a lot to take in! To add to the frustration none of them will work "across the board". Compared to lets say a Blu-ray player where you can play almost every format known to man, including Blu-ray, DVD, CD, HD DVD [combo player], VHS (Yes that´s right, VHS!) and more! Adding to the irony, many also have the ability to stream content from places like Netflix and soon Blockbuster!
5. Restrictions, Restrictions! When Digital Downloads were ushered in it meant doom for users who imported their movies. Before, region coding was the only issue to worry about, with downloads restrictions are but not limited to:
ISP Locks: In today's day and age it's not hard for providers to cut you off solely based on the country your connection is coming from.
D.R.M.X!: You may have heard of Digital Rights Management, but have you heard of Digital Rights Management Xtreme! before? With Digital Distributed content, DRM has been taken to new heights, giving you viewing windows, HDD locks, and a whole slew of other nasty surprises.
The Studio Equation: Believe it or not, studios only want you to give them money when they tell you too! Despite the digital market being capable of providing millions in revenue, studios choose to ignore the market or limit them. There's a reason why your countries XBLVM only has 10 HD movies while the American store has close to 1000.
6. So Easy Howard Stern Can Do It! Pop in your disc/tape and play, simple isn't it? Compared to downloads -- where you have to find the movie you want to watch, queue, optionally wait for it to download, find where the file is stored, and playback -- if necessary, take time out of your experience to watch the buffer bar load.
7. Instant Access It goes without saying, if you want a top quality video distributed digitally, streaming just won't cut it.
8. "I always feel like somebody's watching me" If you tend to use your VUDU box or Bit Torrent Client (Legally we hope) at least once a day to watch your HD/HDX movies, odds are someone will take notice. We won't blame you if you decide to watch Tropic Thunder while your neighbor gets fined and/or arrested for "piracy".
9. It's Not a Wired World! Shockingly surprising yes we know, their are locations in this world that have have little to no Internet access at all (even in North America!)! Despite not even having 56K access, there is a really good chance those locations have access to at least one form physical media to enjoy.
10. No Back Up Plan In a Democratic system, a company is capable of losing millions overnight, the unfortunate case for many is they are forced to a shutdown. Suppose your favorite content provider is forced to shut down their servers for any reason, any content you bought would be gone! Any DRM server checks needed for content to work would fail, leaving you with an empty shell of a movie/album/game. Although some services, such as Microsoft Digital Locker (recently confirmed to be shutting down next August, 2009) allow you to back up your data periodically, unfortunately this model is yet to applied to any other service.
Disclaimer If your product and/or service was mentioned, it's not because were targeting you or anything, it was just an unbiased example.
[END]
Connect to Facebook/Twitter, recommend via email and much more.
Latest headlines
2012 leads this week's box-office Top Ten »
Nov 19, 2009
Megafault will be released November 29 »
Nov 18, 2009
Keatsian love story comes to DVD. »
Nov 18, 2009
This Week on DVD and Blu-ray - November 17th, 2009 »
Nov 17, 2009
Most read
This Week on DVD and Blu-ray - November 17th, 2009 »
Nov 17, 2009

StevePro
June 2006
My links
View profile »View collection »
View wish list »
1. People like physical - Of course they do. My collection of SDs, HDDVDs and BDs look great on my bookshelves. And I can play them any time I want. There are people on this forum who still value their LD collections. This mindset will not change. And it shouldn't.
3. You can't sell digital - You can't show off your digital collection on your bookshelf either. HDDVDs and BDs could be valuable to the right collector in the future. Or maybe they won't: it's a gamble. My collection of 45rpm doo-wop records is now worth a small fortune. Things that I bought for 2 or 3 bucks in the 1960s are now worth hundreds. $7.99 HDDVDs at Blockbuster? I'm scooping those up. 'Ya just never know.
5. Restrictions, restrictions - DRMX, you gotta be kidding. If I bought it, I want to use it when I want to, where I want to and as many times as I want to. I loved the HDDVD combo disks. I have no love for BD Digital Copy.
8 ...someone watching me - Yeah, right. If you can see them, they can see you. We discussed this before. No thanks.
Falcon01
July 2006
My links
View profile »View collection »
Being able to trade/sell the movies is a big deal for me.
ReaggieP
January 2008
My links
View profile »bladerunner1
March 2008
My links
View profile »[Post edited by bladerunner1 on Dec 30, 2008 - CST 3:03 AM]
S_Coaster
May 2004
My links
View profile »View wish list »
Distributors though think otherwise.
They think profit margins. They don't care if you wanna show off to your friends. all they care is minimize loss and increase profit.
DjfunkmasterG
January 2008
My links
View profile »